Reviews For Truth or Shrink
You must login (register) to review.
Reviewer: HectorVanDyne Signed starstarstarstarstar [Report This]
Date: September 03 2015 11:44 PM Title: Chapter 3: Guilt Trip

If Tom had to pick, which of his siblings would you say he'd prefer to be the one that holds him?



Author's Response:

The next few chapters will answer this pretty clearly.

Reviewer: Barrowman Signed [Report This]
Date: September 03 2015 10:33 AM Title: Chapter 3: Guilt Trip

It's hard to give an opinion about the charaters. We know so little yet. For a world where telling the truth is so important, they are very tolerant of him from what I read so far. His family doesn't seem to hate him.
Tom Baker also seems to accept his fate and doesn't mind very much being handled by others so far. Compulsive liers are very annoying. But there is probably more behind Tom Bakers behaviour than meets the eye.
But it's more about Tom having fun. I like his 'I don't care what you do to me attitude' so far.

 

 



Author's Response:

You're right that Tom's family don't hate him, except for maybe Alaina, who at least resents him a lot. They're just used to it by now and have learned to accept him, even if they believe they have to punish him sometimes. You raise some good questions about Tom himself that I will avoid answering now so I don't spoil anything, but you're on the right track.

Reviewer: aaron Signed starstarstarstarstar [Report This]
Date: September 03 2015 2:15 AM Title: Chapter 3: Guilt Trip

This is a disturbing universe indeed, lol. Everyone who lies shrinks. And the severity or quantity of lies determines the size. Sounds like some of us would lie for the hell of it. Cool that you mentioned some teachers having shrunken before. Can't wait to see Alaina in action if/when her home economics teacher tells her that her spaghetti takes wonderful. Man the more I think about it the more possibilities you have to move forward with this story.
Can't wait to see what happens next.

aaron
PS hope the principal is an avid truth teller and likes to "punish" liars with some random "maintenance" ;p (thats a wink with a tongue sticking out but I'm new to those things... Emoticons)

Author's Response:

There would definitely be people like us taking advantage of the system. Fun image for that to happen with a teacher, though most reductions are very slight. So if a teacher were to tell a white lie, they'd probably just lose a few inches. Tom is a special case in that way, because he so often goes down so low. I hope you like what I have planned though.

Well, the principal may not be the person filling that role, but we will meet one particular staff member of the school for whom truth is pretty important.

Reviewer: AdamX Signed starstarstarstarstar [Report This]
Date: September 02 2015 11:28 PM Title: Chapter 3: Guilt Trip

Ah Alania, taking over where Carly was rudely removed from and Maggie seemed to soften on.

 

Good stuff Smithy.



Author's Response:

Hehe. Well, don't count Carly or Maggie out forever! The universe has a way of slipping things back into order...

Reviewer: GiantessLover122 Signed [Report This]
Date: September 02 2015 8:19 PM Title: Chapter 3: Guilt Trip

I hated this chapter.

*shrinks 3 inches*

You're one of the worst writers on this site.

*shrinks 5 inches*

 

Okay, so I couldn't resist. Who could blame me?



Author's Response:

Those kinds of lies are worth far bigger shrink increments than that.

Reviewer: Carycomic Signed starstarstarstarstar [Report This]
Date: September 02 2015 8:15 PM Title: Chapter 3: Guilt Trip

I was giving my brain some much-needed comedy relief after all the astronomical data I had to memorize for chapter 1 of THBS. Just so I could keep my promise to Mr. G!

Author's Response:

Ah. The relief may not be quiiite as comedic later on, but I'm glad you checked it out!

Reviewer: smoki1020 Signed [Report This]
Date: September 02 2015 12:28 PM Title: Chapter 3: Guilt Trip

I agree with tomspeedy about sibling's personalities but i am surprised that even teachers are caught in lying. this fact gonna be awesome to explain!!!!!!!!



Author's Response:

In this world, it's likely that most people at some time or another have lied, even if it's just a small one. Alaina meant that even though Tom is so much younger than his adult teachers, he has lied more than any of them.

Reviewer: TomSpeedy Signed starstarstarstarstar [Report This]
Date: September 02 2015 11:42 AM Title: Chapter 3: Guilt Trip

Yeah, the first person thing was more like a one time thing, but I might do it again soon.

I could also say a lot from Tom's perspective from that chapter but don't know much about how Tom feels about his siblings to do so.

So we got 3 other siblings, each with very different personalities. Alaina is the tough, serious girl who does not mess around. Blake is that brother who doesn't seem to care much, and Emma does care, but she's in the more playful mood compared to Alaina.

There was one sentence at the end of the chapter that kinda confused me and I wasn't sure what you meant. "You're going to start shaping up before you become a problem for you. Aren't you?" I don't know, it just sounds off to me.

What I also liked about this chapter is how experienced these siblings are at telling the truth. I was trying to spot a lie in this chapter but I couldn't guarantee any. Also good move about showing Blake becoming honest. It summarizes their relationship to each other and how well they can tell the truth even if it upsets others.

Anyway, another good chapter, and I can't wait for the next one!

Author's Response:

It's interesting that you point out the limitations on Tom's perspective so far; that's definitely intentional, and the reason for it will be shown later on. Good interpretations of his siblings. That sentence of Alaina's was a play on the phrase "...become a problem for me..." but she replaced it with "you," implying that if he becomes a problem for her, then she'll punish him for it. They all definitely have a better grasp on telling the truth than Tom. Thanks for reading!

Reviewer: Carycomic Signed starstarstarstarstar [Report This]
Date: September 02 2015 11:07 AM Title: Chapter 3: Guilt Trip

As Burt "The Youthful" Ward might say: "Holy Miniature Rollers, Batman!"

Author's Response:

I was surprised to see your name in the reviews for this one, as you seem to comment more on my narrative-centric stories, rather than the ones more concerned with fetish-action like this one. However, I'm glad you're enjoying it!

You must login (register) to review.