Reviews For My generous sister
You must login (register) to review.
Reviewer: Tiny_pet_or_slave Signed [Report This]
Date: March 23 2016 5:17 PM Title: The truth is revealed

Ok I don't know who you are but that was easily one of the best giantess stories I have ever read. Great job. 5 out of 5 stars. I loved every second of it

Reviewer: Simpson3k Signed starstarstarhalf-star [Report This]
Date: December 29 2015 4:41 PM Title: The truth is revealed

Really a great story with the caring sister having no choice but to stuff him back, back there and really well described and all. Sadly with the reveal of the younger sister it kind of went mainstream..the bratty, sadistic little sister..

 

But i´ll keep treasuring chapter 1 till 5 :)

Reviewer: takuoni Signed [Report This]
Date: November 22 2015 1:47 AM Title: The truth is revealed

More pls

Reviewer: giantessfan9 Signed starstarstarstarstar [Report This]
Date: November 10 2015 2:00 AM Title: Handing you over

loving the story so far!

Reviewer: Shrunken Mazerunner Signed [Report This]
Date: October 24 2015 8:16 AM Title: A bad start

This story could've been a lot better. Now I've only read the first 2 chapters so maybe you already fixed some of the things that I'm going to critque. Also I'm not yelling at you or anything, I'm just trying to give some helpful adivce. 

The frst thing that I noticed was the "you"s instead of "I"s. Now abc has already talked a lot about this so I'll just say one thing about it. More people will want to read a story in the 1st preson. 

The second thing is that in the first chapter you changed precpetives. "...she was caring and looked after me as well as my younger sister Tilly. You notice that she is..." I had to go back and re-read that three or four times to truly understand what it was saying. You also have a lot of grammar and spelling errors, but I'm not gonna be too picky on that. Mainly because I suck with grammar and spelling too.

The next thing is that Chole goes out of charater in the 2nd chapter. You describe her as gentle in the 1st, but then she insults her brother in the 2nd. Now maybe that's based on personal exp., however I am an older brother I care for my little bro yet I don't insult him....much. If I were to insult him I'd atleast say his n

 

Last and, in my opinion, most important is detail. You don't have enough. You say in the first chapter "...you see a blonde figure standing in the doorway." It's great that you told us her hair color, but we want to know more about her. Is she tall? What are her facical features? Is she skinny, or large? What color are her eyes? You get the idea. Going into detail helps the reader. The reader should be able to have a high quataily movie of your book playing in their head as they read. Now, like I said, I've only read the first two chapters so maybe you've already been adding more deatil.

I want to say again, this was in no way ment to be rude or insulting. I'm just trying to give you some tips on how to make a great story. For a first story, it's not that bad.      



Author's Response: I understand your concerns, but it's all done on purpose. I've never been good at detail or decent grammar, and it's not getting any better. So, I don't add in some detail as I'll struggle to describe it or it won't work or something like that. This then makes the reader able to use their imagination. It's just how I like to write. Also, I noticed that the "you" styled chapters haven't really clicked. Therefore, I'll only use it in this story and will use "I" or "he/she" in future stories.

Reviewer: abc3643 Signed [Report This]
Date: October 17 2015 8:17 PM Title: A bad start

Author's Response: Just saying I'm not the first to do this on this website and I won't be the last

I know and I feel bad like I am picking on you.  You just happen to be the straw that broke the camel's back and perhaps that's because I am under the impression that you are female and that it seems that you actually have some talent.  I want to encourage that and my criticism is actually constructive.  So, if not this story, consider writing your next one without the "You" construct.



Author's Response: Ok then. Plus I'm not female

Author's Response: Ok then. Plus I'm not female

Reviewer: abc3643 Signed [Report This]
Date: October 16 2015 8:00 PM Title: A bad start

Author's Response: Actually, I like using 'you' in some of my stories as makes the reader feel like that it's happening/happened to them.

Actually, most readers don't like that.  It makes them feel like puppets and its forced and unreal.  You describe an action "You" takes and your reader thinks "I wouldn't do that."  Immediately, the reader begins to have issues.  Notice that there is not a single play or work of published fiction which uses this technique and it is primarily for that reason.

Evem on TV shows like Blues Clues or Dora the Explorer, when the characters try to engage the toddlers watching the show, the character asks the toddler's questions nit doesn't give orders.

So, you have likely a fine story, but you should consider writing again - create a new story with the same theme - but from a different perspective.  In fact, that's what's happening right now with 50 Shades of Grey: now there is a new novel told from Grey's perspective.



Author's Response: Just saying I'm not the first to do this on this website and I won't be the last

Reviewer: Max333 Signed starstarstarstarstar [Report This]
Date: October 16 2015 4:32 PM Title: A bad start

Yet again a wonderful chapter, can't wait to know how wicked his sister really is :)



Author's Response: Hold up, I never said anything about her being wicked........

Reviewer: abc3643 Signed [Report This]
Date: October 16 2015 2:36 PM Title: A bad start

Try rewritting this without "You".  No work of fiction is ever really written like that.  Give "You" a name and write it in the 3rd person or 1st person.

 

 



Author's Response: Actually, I like using 'you' in some of my stories as makes the reader feel like that it's happening/happened to them.

Reviewer: Max333 Signed starstarstarstarstar [Report This]
Date: October 16 2015 7:21 AM Title: A bad start

Hey there, really nice story so far ! Can't wait to see what will happen now :)
Please do continue ! 

Reviewer: Senital2011 Signed [Report This]
Date: October 05 2015 12:58 AM Title: A bad start

Interesting. Please do keep going. I see this is your first so welcome. A point or two. Different character get new lines of text. It'll make it more space out and its easier to read and differentiate between charecters. Look forward to what comes next. 



Author's Response: Cheers :)

You must login (register) to review.