Reviewer: squashed123 Signed
Date: June 18 2021
Title: Chapter 1: Mom's Life Lesson
Boy, I hate to see Aubreigh doubling back. She was shaping up so nicely. Try not to get cornered in a back-and-forth kind of situation, because it's really annoying to keep the story going from that point on. I know what I'm talking about there, sadly.
I think in total, this chapter (Family Drama) was a bit lackluster and overloaded at the same time. There's so much going on, things changing really fast and very little development. The crushing at the end didn't feel like it actually served a purpose.
Just leaving this here as some constructive (and real) criticism. I still love this story a lot and I've been checking practically every hour since your last upload if there's been an update. I mean, this story has so much potential: the family life, the company (oh my god the company!), general society and so on.
Natalie works because she is manipulative, callous, selfish and a number of other awesome things. When she starts to care, second-guess herself or generally show weakness, a large part of her character becomes lost. To me it feels like this was the case here. Remember how she killed those three people in "The Drive Back Home". Two were murdered out of annoyance or convenience and the third just as a sort of prank. In one or two paragraphs, you encapsuled pages of character building, putting the crown on everything you built her up to. This time, she panics, she can't control herself, she cries, she kills someone accidentally and then someone else without even looking who it is - all to teach some lesson to Thomas? It doesn't make sense to me.
When she wanted to kill Brian, that was SHE in the flesh, although she would probably have made sure his family can see her kill him, just out of spite. She chickened out of that one on some really weird pretext, wanting him to tell lies on her behalf that would have accomplished...what exactly? And why would she eat somebody that's been drenched in her own foot sweat for several hours? That's disgusting.
My criticism always sounds harsher than I mean it. Really, no hard feelings. I just love this story so much. Please do with this critique what you will.
Cheers
Author's Response: Hey squashed, thanks for the review. You really brought things into perspective.
Yeah, I was really angling for the redemption route for Aubreigh. I imagined her taking the tinies to a mini city (to "save" then) against her mother's will, creating a huge rift between her and her mom, of course. Then when she shrank, her mom would dominate and torture her to find out where they were. Which in turn, would create more animosity between Aubreigh and the other tinies for selling them out. Seemed like a fun idea at the time, but I dunno... maybe not!
But you're right about Natalie and I regret the writing for this chapter with her. I thought it would be interesting or funny that she TRIES to treat her husband better than regular tinies... but then would miserably fail at that until just giving up and treating him just like the others. But now I'm asking myself why I wanted to explore such a convoluted route to that end... bleh...
I'm going to take a break from this story. Part of the writing issues that you mentioned stem from the fact that I've changed my outline about half a dozen times every couple chapters or so... then when I change my mind again... we'll then I've already written myself into a corner and have to work with what's left. Oh well, you win some you lose some I guess. Just got to figure out where to go from here.
But absolutely thank you for your review and critique. You caught a lot of stuff I didn't realize... but once it was pionted out for me, I knew exactly what/where the problem was.