Reviews For The Right Choice
You must login (register) to review.
Reviewer: lightwing Signed [Report This]
Date: January 03 2023 8:44 PM Title: Chapter 4

Oh wow, that last part of the scared lilliputian woman in the vial in the guli woman's purse means he saved someone who does treat his kind poorly.  Hopefully she treated her latest toy nicely after this instead of whatever she was going to do.  At least during the interview she seemed to have had a change of heart, mentioning that she was wrong about "people of his background".

Personally, I'm fond of stories where a "bad" giantess has a change of heart for whatever reason and becomes good, possibly feeling guilt for their past cruel actions.  It looks like this Guli will be going down that path.

Author's Response:

Thatís the real question here. Did he make the right choice? Itís unclear, but maybe you have an opinion on it? I hope it makes you think. 

I also like stories like that. However, in this one itís not clear of she really means it. Heíd like to think so, but after what he saw, can you blame him for being wary? More food for thought. 

Reviewer: Acrophite Signed starstarstarstarstar [Report This]
Date: November 16 2022 8:13 PM Title: Chapter 4

Extremely impressive short story. Many thoughts, let’s get into it. 

I am impressed with the detailed surgery performed in chapter 3, and it looks like either you did extensive research or have that kind of knowledge already. And enough knowledge to creatively use it with the size difference just adds to this. I love it, and it’s definitely the highlight here. 

The theme here is also fantastic and quite similar to Magna Gratia, but different questions are brought up here. Is it ever wrong to deny help to someone who does evil things? Is someone an evil person based on what they do and is there redemption in that? Having it revealed that the Gulli owns a Lilli really adds a whole new layer to the fear our protagonist has. Typically you would say that you should help anyone, that is the good thing to do, but she treats his kind as property. Does that make her less worthy of care and having her life spared? So much to discuss there, and I love how that is tapped into. Would love to have that explored either in a sequel to this or have that included in Magna Gratia. 

Overall, fantastic and would love to see more short stories that delve into concepts Magna Gratia won’t or can’t.

Author's Response:

I'm glad you enjoyed it. Unfortunately, this story hasn't gotten much attention as I'd hoped. I'll share my thoughts as well.

I'm no surgeon but I did my research and consulted with some med student friends of mine. I didn't want to overload the story with medical terms, but I couldn't just ignore them either. I think the balance was good in terms of readability. Operating on a giant patient was an idea I hadn't seen done before, so I gave it a shot. The task would've been difficult given the proper tools, not that he had them. Having him improvise and race against time was all part of making the situation dire. I wanted the reader to feel his stress.

The theme of my stories tend to be pretty similar, since they take place in the same world. MG takes place in New Brobdingnag (annexed Lilliput), whereas TRC happens in Gulliveria (where many Lillis live). Unlike MG, this was much darker. The protagonist is cynical for a reason, but when the time came, he had to make a choice. There was no guarantee that he could save her, but he was willing to try anyway. Sometimes life puts you in a difficult position. In this case, he had nothing to gain and (potentially) a lot to lose. I made it a point never to say whether what he did was right or wrong. I believe that should be decided by the reader. The story title isn't a statement--it's a question:

"[What is] The Right Choice[?]"

Considering it was a one-off, I have no plans to continue it. However, similar ideas may be explored in MG, if not other short stories. MG is very lighthearted, but I'm not one to shy away from darker topics. I draw the line at graphic violence, gore, and descriptions of death, but everything else is fair game. I already have a short story in the works that focuses on war and peace. I hope you'll read it when I finally write it.

Reviewer: writer23 Signed starstarstarstarstar [Report This]
Date: June 11 2022 3:57 PM Title: Chapter 4

What a strange and interesting short story.

Author's Response:

Thanks! I think that's a compliment? Haha

Reviewer: SizePrincess Signed [Report This]
Date: June 09 2022 5:11 PM Title: Chapter 1

This story has an interesting premise. I always love reading Guliveran size based society stuff. 

You've written a good intro here and I'm looking forward to seeing more chapters as well as how these characters are going to interact. 

Author's Response:

Thank you! It's a 4 chapter short story so don't expect anything crazy. I'm looking to upload chapter 3 in a few days so stay tuned :)

Reviewer: SlashMaster Signed [Report This]
Date: June 09 2022 4:33 AM Title: Chapter 1

Do you do commissions?

Author's Response:

Depends. I wouldn't take on anything I'm not comfortable writing about. Contact me by email through this site

Reviewer: vegetaboy Signed starstarstarstarstar [Report This]
Date: June 09 2022 2:50 AM Title: Chapter 2

Ok, I am intrigued to see where this goes :) 

I think you did a great job setting up the world from the main character's perspective, and the weight of the decision he now faces. 

I can't wait to see what happens next, you've done a great job on these chapters. 

Author's Response:

That means a lot to me, thanks so much! I hope the next two chapters live up to your expectations.

You must login (register) to review.