Reviewer: It Was Me Signed
Date: April 26 2023
Title: Chapter 1: They're Coming to Get You Barbara!
Barb did a double take, the corpse of Mrs. Smythe, her old landlady, was dead in front of her
I'm not really much of a pun person, but this one … this one got me. Well done!
Also, Night of the Living Dead, Zombieland, AND Metal Gear Solid references all in the same chapter? What?! That Zombieland one was brutal, too.
And right off the bat, this chapter shows that Peter's concerns about Celia's leadership from chapter two (the ones about food, power, and water) are legitimate. Even though those particular issues don't come up, the way she handles the new arrivals has me convinced that the mall group won't last more than a couple weeks with her in charge. She made absolutely no effort to evaluate the skillsets of anyone she brought in to see what they can contribute. Of course, almost all of the tinies are all relegated to nail work, while her fellow giants are forced to show team spirit or face the unbearable punishment of mall employment.
That's not a complaint, mind you. It makes sense that she's not practical, and her introduction to the new arrivals showed off her bubbly demeanor and delusion while giving the new West State University Cheerleading recruits a peak at her dark side. I'm still really loving her as a villain.
I'm also interested to see how things shake out with Rhames. I don't think we have enough information to see which side he ends up taking (once there are sides to take). There seems to be a sense of respect between Celia and him, and if he thinks she's his best chance of survival, I could see him going her way (based on what little we know about him so far).
The banter between Barb and John continues to be charming and fun. Also, in Barb's defense about Leon, if you look at the history of Resident Evil, groups typically don't do very well. You usually only end up with one or two people left anyway. The president was probably just trying to save some time!
But it's still really endearing to see how tight the two main characters have become in such a short amount of time. Chapter one Barb certainly wouldn't have been confident enough to be so assertive (and she also likely would have been worried that John might misread her playfulness for actual coercion), and I think John would have found that assertiveness less sexy and more terrifying early on.
That little heart-to-heart they had was nice as well. It's kind of sad that Barb sees herself as a loser, but that just makes her building herself up through John that much more satisfying at the same time. And it's nice to see that she's having the same effect on him as well.
But most impressive is that their progression just feels natural. Compliment each other, indeed. If your other stuff has character development this good, I really need to check them out!
The forklift plan worked a lot better than I thought it would. It continued to show why Barb is such a fun protagonist, too. And while Mrs. Smythe may not exactly be a Bub analog, she comes pretty close in her brief time in this chapter. I wonder how her Aunt Alicia is doing?
I have to admit, I was a little surprised at how fast Celia came to rescue there at the end of the chapter. When Cassie went out to save Barb, I thought she was either going to find herself locked out and forced to find another place to escape to or be made to sweat it out until the last possible second. At first, I thought maybe Celia did it because it would be a bad look to let one of their own die in front of the rest of the cheerleaders. Then I thought maybe it was some weird parallel between Celia and the zombies, as in much like how Mrs. Smythe still craves rent, the cheer captain warlord still maintains the same loyalty she had for squadmates in the old world.
And then, once they were inside, Celia darkly reminded Cassie to call her by her title instead of her name, and something clicked for me. I think I had previously underestimated how much Celia actually likes Cassie.
I hadn't realized until that point that Celia had let Cassie get away with calling her by her name while on duty during their conversation on the roof (I know Cassie called her Celia in the last chapter as well, but I figured that Cassie was off duty since she was getting her nails done). It also seemed as though Celia was almost trying to make an effort to suppress her anger when Cassie called her out about Peter, and it was like Celia was trying to convince her to see things her way, which is vastly different from the treatment nameless cheerleader received for suggesting they try to contact other people in chapter one.
I'm starting to think that Celia sees Cassie as an actual friend (or as close to a friend as someone like Celia can actually have) rather than just a subordinate. She even shortened her name to Cass once, which gave that conversation a more personal feel than any other we've seen from Celia so far.
If Celia does feel that way, this probably doesn't bode well for Peter. Between Cassie standing up for him and those glances they shared (which I'm sure Celia could plainly see), he may make the unpleasant transition in Celia's eyes from crush and source of entertainment to bad influence pretty quickly.
Or I could be reading way too much into all this. Either way, it'll be interesting to see how the relationship between the two girls plays out going forward.
And finally, the long awaited (three whole chapters) confrontation between Barb and her former bully. It was nice to see John sticking up for Barb, but hopefully they've seen enough to realize that they may not want to let Celia know how close they've gotten. Otherwise, the mall might be offering a two-for-one bullying special, as abusing John would surely get to Barb as well.
Then again, this could be a good chance to find out if Barb's newfound confidence has staying power or if she reverts back to her self-defeating attitude as she has to endure who knows what from her old enemy.
I wonder if will Barb get to go through tryouts or if she'll be immediately relegated to mall worker (or something worse).
Author's Response: Your reviews are always a treat to read. Yeah Celia certainly has strengths as a leader, she's got a loyal and well disciplined group and she's also ruthless and quick thinking, the problem is she's also going off the deep end and thinks the cheer squad is a great model for a new society.
Barb and John haven't had much time together, but life and death situations and the bluntness of the zombie apocalypse speed along those relationships you might say. Personally I like giant and tiny characters that compliment each other in some way, I'm not sure what, if any, of my other stories you've read but I do try to show character and relationship arcs over the story. A lot of people think my story One Year Lease is pretty good on this, and if you review any of my other stories I'd love to hear thoughts about them!
Rhames is a reference to Ving Rhames' Dawn of the Dead character. He's obviously not loyal enough to his fellow tinies to try to help them out too much, he and Celia have a weird respect thing because they recognize that they both have to be somewhat harsh to get respect in this world, Celia might be "big" relative to the tiny characters, but she's still a pretty cheerleader, like Rhames said she'd have to understand certain things to be able to be in charge in this world.
On Celia and Cassie yes Celia and Cassie are close, or were before the end of the world, and it reflects in how Cassie is able to talk with her more informally than the other cheerleaders get to. Cassie's breaking point in this chapter was actually a High School of the Dead homage of sorts, Celia's rescue is both because she can't be seen to abandon one of her own and like you said Cassie is a friend, although how long that will last is now very much up in the air.
Obviously nothing good awaits our heroes in the mall under Celia's rule, Barb's grown up a bit, but Celia's also not the same preppy bully she was either.